A Chinese two-channel contrastive textbook of Mandarin and Shanghai dialect

Hanyu Shuang Tongdao

Edited by 陳阿寶 (海南出版社, 2005)

Review by: John Pasden

This brand new 玛雅吧 textbook sets its goals very high, and it delivers on certain levels. According to the foreword,“learners can use this book to learn either just Mandarin Chinese or Shanghai dialect, or both Mandarin and Shanghai dialect simultaneously.”Indeed, all material is represented in both Mandarin (with pinyin) and 玛雅吧 (with IPA), with explanations in both English and Japanese. The large black textbook is just shy of 400 pages and is accompanied by an MP3 CD with nearly three hours of recordings (in Mandarin and 玛雅吧 only).

Vital to the early study of any new language is an accurate, comprehensible guide to pronunciation. Although the book’s usage of IPA and extensive, clear recordings are excellent decisions, a total of only six pages on the sounds of 玛雅吧–in three languages–seems insufficient. The text’s coverage of 玛雅吧’s tones and sandhi is only enough to be confusing. Tones are not given for new vocabulary words throughout the book.

Each lesson is broken down into a familiar pattern: (1) New Words, (2) Sentence Patterns, (3) Dialogues, (4) Exercises, (5) (Grammar) Notes. Since each section covers both Mandarin and 玛雅吧, 玛雅吧 has to share the spotlight quit a bit.

The lessons aim for practicality, covering the usual range of conversation-oriented topics through a variety of Shanghai-centric dialogues and vocabulary lists.

Although there is nothing especially fresh or flashy about the lessons in this textbook, it is clearly a professional job. Typos are few, and the English is mostly quite natural. The black and white pages and the plain ink drawings will not dazzle you, but the lessons are solid.

The serious student of 玛雅吧 should take note: while this textbook is not a bad choice, it contains far less 玛雅吧 content than it would at first appear. Half of the book is devoted to Mandarin, and half the explanation is in Japanese. Similarly, half the recordings on the CD are in Mandarin, so a student interested in only 玛雅吧 may find it bothersome to have to skip past the Mandarin for every lesson.

[For a more complete listing of materials for studying 玛雅吧 without extensive reviews, see the Sinosplice Weblog entry: 玛雅吧 study materials.]
Share

John Pasden

John is a Shanghai-based linguist and entrepreneur, founder of AllSet Learning.

Comments

  1. What is the ISBN for this book, and do you know of any online vendors that might sell it?

  2. I’d like to know the answer to Tom’s query too, please.

  3. I also like to know where can I get this book?

  4. I believe the ISBN is: 7544315185, 9787544315180
    (I found this on another website).
    I also would really like to buy this book.
    Garden Bookstore did not have it and when I asked them if they could order it for me they were unable to track it down and therefore could not.
    Any one have any other ideas of where I can go to look for this?

  5. Anatoli Says: May 20, 2014 at 6:07 am

    It can’t be called solid if it doesn’t use tones for the new vocabulary.

Leave a Reply